Why can't women get closer to God through pleasant smells?

By -

I found the idea that women's use of aromatic items being seen as witchcraft, which is explained in the following quote, pretty sexist, but also thought provoking.

“Perfume, for example, which is often associated with romance, sexuality, and tranquility, can be viewed quite positively when referring to God (with attendant images of mercy and memory) but may have strong negative associations (witchcraft and idolatry) when applied to women” (Green, 15).

The fact that when rabbis would burn incense, it was seen as something being done to be closer to God, but if women were to burn incense, it would be assumed that it was for witchcraft bothers me. It states that rabbis have taught that if you walk past a town and smell and pleasant scent you should only say a blessing if you know that a majority of the inhabitants are Israelites, as you wouldn’t want to say a blessing over idolaters using incense for witchcraft or those using it for garment scenting. However, Rabbi Yossi states that even if the town is majority Israelite, not to say a blessing because the daughters of Israel light incense for witchcraft. I understand that they didn’t want to bless idolatry or garment scenting, it’s the assumption that any woman who lit incense was using it for witchcraft or garment scenting that I can’t get behind. 

If you compare that to the idea that women are always expected to have a pleasant scent, then and now, it further implies that all women practice witchcraft. This implication found in these two cases actively contradicts the idea of being closer to God with pleasant scents. If pleasant scents are to be blessed and bring you closer to God then it doesn’t make sense that women who burn incense would be assumed to be idolaters. Why not assume that they too want to be closer to God?


Comments

  1. SaachiMay 12, 2022 at 8:32 AM

    I feel similarly about the connection you made to women being called witches for smells in the past, and now having to face the expectation of always smelling good. I have always seen smells of flowers and delicate things in nature being annotated and feminine, however it is interesting to see how when they were actually put to use, it backfired on women. I think much of this discrimination come from the double standards our society has always had for women, especially those that intimidate society.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Amidst the Pandemic

By -
Image
I think having the opportunity to take Smells and Bells and then experiencing a worldwide pandemic came with good timing. Oftentimes, we’re so rushed to get from one one place to another that we miss out on what happens around us. We’re so accustomed to the lifestyle of being busy that it has become the norm for many of us. However, the pandemic has forced us to slow down. We’re now appreciating everything that we had previously taken for granted and noticing things in our surroundings that we have never noticed before.  Take this quarantining/social distancing as an opportunity to be more aware of what you experience through the senses. I don’t think my senses have necessarily heightened over the past 5 weeks, but I am actively making the choice to pay more attention to what I see, hear, touch, taste, and smell. I like going on nature/mindfulness walks and basking in the sunshine out in my backyard. This morning, I could hear a faint noise from the wind, hear the birds chirping, f
Read more

Food in the Afterlife

By -
Image
In Religion in the Kitchen: Cooking, Talking, and the Making of Black Atlantic Traditions , Perez talks of Ashabi and her grandchildren providing food offerings to their ancestors. This immediately reminded me of the practice of food sacrifice in early China. I've taken Chinese language classes for about 7 years now and in one of the lessons, we learned about food as well as the history of food in Chinese culture. Ashabi and her grandchildren would give food offerings to their ancestors every day. This included nine beverages (coffee, liquor, and water mixed with sugar and molasses) and nine square pieces of coconut topped with red palm oil and guinea pepper. The offerings would also include whatever food was dropped on the ground. In their house, food dropping on the floor signified more than it would in common American households. It signified that the ancestors wanted that food and had willingly made it fall to the floor. They also used dishware that had been chipped which was
Read more