All Scents in Love and War

By -

I wasn't sure what to write about for this reading until yesterday. After class, I reread the last section of the reading from Tuesday and it gave me a lot to think about. The sentence "The aroma of victory and the stench of death, decay, and defeat are identical in terms of smell but represent opposite values..." struck a chord in me because of the atrocities currently occurring in Ukraine. What do bomb sites smell like, or burning bodies, or homes that have been abandoned by the people who once celebrated life there.

 https://nnc.com.ng/

One of my closest friend's entire family is from Ukraine and I remember what she told me after coming home from a three week long trip to visit her family there many years ago. Apparently, it is customary in Ukraine for visitors to be fed a lot and they cannot say no or else it is considered extremely impolite. My friend laughed as she remembered how much food was being given to them everywhere they went and how the "offering" of seconds wasn't really a question. The joke was how they were so full from the trip that they wouldn't be able hungry again for a month. The memory of her telling me that has been playing over and over in my mind. I can only imagine the amazing smells that once permeated the now many abandoned homes and how Ukrainians might never be able return to these homes and their culture. 

I saw a video of a father saying goodbye to his wife and daughter as he sent them to a safe zone. The father pressed his nose and face into his daughters hair. The importance of scent memory seemed crucial in this moment. The scents of love, friends and family have been replaced by death, decay, and gasoline from thousands of vehicles fleeing to safety. Never before have I considered the scent of victory in war and it is a horrific one.

Comments

  1. Violet WindhamFebruary 25, 2022 at 12:24 PM

    This is a really powerful post, Eliza. I saw the video of the father saying goodbye to his family, and my heart shattered. Your last sentence, "Never before have I considered the scent of victory in war and it is a horrific one" made me think about how disturbing, unsettling and completely traumatizing this conflict is for the people of Ukraine. Thank you for sharing your perspective

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jonathan Brumberg-KrausFebruary 25, 2022 at 12:57 PM

    I agree with Violet about your post. It's the pathos of the dramatically opposite emotional affects of the smells in the rabbis' interpretations and in your evocation of the good and horrific smells from Ukraine when you put them in mind side by side that make them so powerful.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The most primitive sense

By -
Image
Smell the Flowers by Kirsten Star Smell, to me, is the most primitive sense. When most mammals are born, they immediately can recognize their mother’s smell and form an attachment to that smell. Mammals like puppies are almost entirely limited to only the sense of smell until they develop more of their other senses. The sense of smell also becomes the most primitive when considering humans and the phenomenon of perfume. For years, humans hunted certain animals for the purpose of obtaining the musk produced in the anal gland. This musk in small doses can act as an aphrodisiac when put into a perfume even though it has incredibly primitive origins. Though most of Western culture has an aversion to smells considered gross or undesirable, the wealthiest of women are still willing to pay heavy prices to spray a smell once obtained from the anal glands of other animals. The sense of smell is not something that humans can control and adjust but rather it is only changed by evolution over
Read more

Cannibalism and Symbolism

By -
Symbolism plays an important role in religious ceremonies because people cannot have the divine being where they want him all the time. So they start creating ways to be in touch with God. Such as in Christianity, eating bread is symbolized to be eating God-made flesh. There are similar rituals in Judaism where they eat the food of God. A big difference between taste and the other senses is that the object that is being sensed is internalized, whereas all the other senses use an external sensation. Taste cannot extend anywhere like the other senses can. This allows the humans to have no barrier between the divine (symbolized as food) and themselves. This is the closest they can get to God, but internalizing Him.  This thought of getting the closest they can to someone by ingesting and gaining power from it led my mind to wander to the thought of serial killers that also happen to be cannibals. I know that it might be a stretch, but there are some similarities. I als
Read more

Wrap-Up Post

By -
Image
Alright, let’s tie this up in a nice little bow. I genuinely did not know what to expect coming into this class. The extent of my knowledge of the senses comes from elementary school when we had to make it a little song to get the information through our tiny heads. Beyond that, everything seemed pretty cut and dry. We have five senses. We need to use all of them to survive. It’s as simple as that. I did not know how there was enough to talk about the senses to fill an entire college course, especially one specifically regarding the relationship between the senses and religion. But the fact that we were barely able to fit all the content in before the semester ended proves just how wrong I was. Let’s talk about why that is and what some of the things I learned were. First off, even the most basic assumption about the senses, that there are five of them, was questioned immediately. The sixth sense may not have been as clearly defined as the other senses, but there was certainly a lot to
Read more